Review: Pitouie by Derek Winkler
![pitouiefront[1] pitouiefront[1]](http://woodenrocketpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/pitouiefront1-193x300.jpg)
PITOUIE
by Derek Winkler
239 pages
available at http://www.theworkhorsery.ca/TheWorkhorsery/shop.html
Some activities can be undertaken lightly. Playing soccer, for example, can easily be a perfectly casual pastime. One can play soccer for an afternoon, and then go back to his life. Having played, it is then a matter of personal choice whether or not one wishes to identify oneself as a soccer player.
Some activities can not be undertaken lightly.
In the window of the Starbucks on Parliament Street, I sat reading the final chapters of Derek Winkler’s Pitouie. With a cup of tea — adequate in that special multi-national corporate way – in one hand, a smile on my face, and the slender volume folded in my lap, I fell asleep. There’s no way around it. I’m the guy who fell asleep in the Starbucks.
It’s not Winkler’s fault, Pitouie is a wonderful and engaging novel. Sleep is not the thesis of my review. I just needed to get that off my chest.
Otis is the “associate editor of Waste Insight magazine,” and protagonist of Winkler’s debut novel. He captured my attention immediately. I quite like it when writers write about writing. There is something particularly engaging about that specific kind of self-reflexive meta-reality, especially when the fictional character purports to have some hand in creating the text. This writer-as-character device is one of a few common threads that link many of my favourite stories – Dracula, Lord of the Rings, Transmetropolitan. In all of these examples, the characters who write are notably skillful, honorific champions of language. This is not so in Pitouie.
It would have been easy to write Otis as a young and cavalier Hunter Thomson figure. To send him boldly to an island in the south pacific, where he would write a damning critique of some large and incomprehensible mime like Corporate America, or Modern Colonialism, or some such thing. That is basically the caper, but that is not Otis. The most fun thing about Pitouie is that it is, rather uniquely, the story of a mid-career journalist who is trapped at the bottom of his industry. Otis is a failure. Not a bitter, or selfish, miserable failure, just a man who has accepted defeat. He hasn’t expended effort in any area of his life for many, many years. Otis, as a lone man with limited skill and no resources, is a beautifully written contrast against the elaborate, and deeply intriguing Pitouie con-job.
The inseminating event of the story is the recept of an e-mail:
“Come discuss how Pitouie Island can free your company to operate creatively and without the restrictions of conventional, regulated international business. Come and see our flexibility and willingness to work with you to meet your goals and solve your waste management problems.”
It’s beauitifully passive. Otis doesn’t go out hunting the story, the story falls into his inbox. The only thing he does of his own volition is accept the invitation, and for once in his small career, Otis decides to research a story. It’s something real reporters do all the time, but something wholly new for him. For Otis, going to the island means doing something good against all momentum, against his own better judgment, against type. It is not an action undertaken lightly and, like falling asleep in a Starbucks, it’s not something he will ever be able to undo.
Pitouie is a story about garbage. Diamond mines, uranium salting, chemical waste disposal, and “barrels of leftover shit.” It’s dangerous territory for a fiction writer. One has to be extremely careful to remember that they are, first and foremost, an entertainer. Incorporating these as themes in a story is fine, fantastic even. No material should be off limits in a work of fiction, but if the writer becomes too emotionally involved in a political message though, they risk damaging the integrity of their narrative in favour of moralization. Winkler does not fall into this bear trap. Pitouie walks a beautiful tightrope around it’s political issues, being an intentionally strange and awesome fictional case study. Winkler cleverly asks environmental questions without too heavily discussing environmental issues.
Winkler’s handling of his narrative is tight and considered. Each chapter is a contained and effective unit, with a crisp dramatic purpose. It is lovely to read a text that has been crafted with this much care. After a hundred or so pages, though, Pitouie begins to feel too bite-sized. I had the feeling that I was being spoon-feed narrative chunks and, while I enjoyed each mouthful, the experience of the meal was a little bit (infantilizing is too harsh a word, but I’ve trapped myself in this metaphor so) infantilizing. Plot twists were never predictable, but also never quite surprising. I was always a step or two ahead of Otis in my investigation of the island mystery.
There is a second narrative thread in Pitouie, which takes place on a military base in the Arctic. Lars, a low ranking radar technician, is driven by boredom to investigate the presence of some mysterious visitors. In the case of this second mystery, the reader is put right in step with Lars, learning each new kernal of information as the character does. It might have been fun for Winkler to try and use this device with Otis as well. It might have helped to give the book a much needed sense of danger.
It is not to say that Winkler took his job as narrator lightly; overall he’s produced a fantastic debut effort with Pitouie. A carefully plotted mystery, an engaging and pithy character sketch, and some tremendously entertaining plot turns make Pitouie an excellent investment for someone seeking a casual, summer read. I would have liked to see a more active and present approach to the Winkler’s passive character. If more had been done to generate a sense of empathy between Otis and the reader, Pitouie could have made for a much more emotional read.
All quotations are from the novel Pitouie by David Winkler.
want to review one of our books? Consider visiting the store before you leave the site.
Marvel Studios made motion picture history last week, when it confirmed a long standing rumour that Earths Sorcerer Supreme, Stephen Strange, would be aloud to play himself in the upcoming Avengers movie. Strange, who is both a practicing medical doctor and a notoriously dedicated archmagus, has been campaigning for this job both with the studio and the public at large for several months. I caught up with the Doctor’s astral self in his Greenwich village condo. We drank a pungent tea, and he granted me sixteen answers to five questions.